Categorize Your Recruiting Interactions

by | Dec 5, 2025

Most real estate recruiters and hiring managers view recruiting as a transaction.

This only makes sense–you get a great sense of satisfaction (and usually a compensation bonus too) from bringing someone across the finish line.

Unfortunately, your recruiting prospects are experiencing something different.

They spend 90% of their time contemplating and preparing to make this significant life change.

If you approach everyone with a transaction mentality, most of your interactions are going to feel awkward, forced, and unwelcome.

Here’s a better way.

Start categorizing your interactions into one of three stages:

Building Awareness (Marketing):The recruiting prospect is just learning who you are and whether you can be trusted.

Career Counseling/Problem Solving (Nurturing):The recruiting prospect is willing to take your advice and share openly about his/her problems and concerns.

Closing the Hire (Selling):The recruiting prospect is ready to make a commitment, and he/she is actively considering options from you and other companies.

If you know where a person is in the recruiting process, you’ll be better equipped to customize your message to meet their needs and expectations.

When a person feels understood, friction is reduced and communication flows more freely.

How much of YOUR time should you spend in each of these stages?

It should also reflect the stages where your prospects are residing—for instance, a reasonable distribution should be something like 60% Marketing—30% Nurturing—10% Selling.

It’s never going to be 90% Selling.

 

The Simple Psychology of Real Estate Recruiting [2nd Edition]

Unlock the secrets of effective real estate recruiting. Revised to include actionable frameworks for sharper execution and to help you turn psychological theory into a repeatable recruiting system.

Agent Migration: Q1 Had Some Big Surprises

Agent Migration: Q1 Had Some Big Surprises

While there’s a lot to digest, it’s critical to apply these insights to your recruiting strategy in the months ahead. That’s one of the reasons we’ve partnered with Lone Wolf to host a live webinar covering the Q1 Agent Migration trends you need to understand to compete effectively. Industry veterans Mark Johnson and Kyle Hunter will lead the session, simplifying the data, prioritizing what matters most, and outlining clear, actionable steps you can take.

How to Get it Right by Being Wrong

How to Get it Right by Being Wrong

There are several well-documented strategies researchers have discovered, but the easiest one to implement quickly is using a structured interview process. Develop a common set of questions for your interviews and record the answers candidates provide (take notes). And then try to hold back judgment until after the interview and when you’ve had time to review your notes.

Doing Only the Things You Like Doing

Doing Only the Things You Like Doing

For most recruiters and hiring managers, recruiting is a complex, end-to-end process containing a bunch of the individual tasks all of which they’re not going to enjoy. Those who push through unpleasant tasks not only find success but also find more satisfaction in the parts of the recruiting process they do enjoy.